Entrepreneurs looking to expand business overseas undoubtedly face a tough choice between Singapore and Dubai. Singapore is considered Asia’s gold standard when it comes to clean and efficient bureaucratic processes and corporate governance. Dubai, on the other hand, bases its attractiveness on its zero corporate income tax rates for most businesses.
Each of these destinations, however, offers unique selling propositions to the startup owner. Singapore is a more diversified economy traversing shipping, manufacturing, trade, banking and finance. The UAE, of which Dubai, is often considered the most liberal of dominions, is majorly an oil-producing economy that has recently stepped up in areas such as retail, trade, and tourism.
This article will attempt to compare and contrast the strengths and weaknesses of each of these destinations for business owners old and new and discuss which situations are best matched for growth in these two very different markets.
Ease of Doing Business
Singapore and UAE have consistently put a lot of work into making their economies more business-friendly and streamlining their administrative procedures. However, as per the World Bank’s Ease of Doing Business report, Singapore typically has better ranks in comparison to the UAE when it comes to business convenience. While Singapore ranks No.2 in the world in ‘Ease of Doing Business’ rankings as of 2020 with a score of 86.2 overall, the UAE ranks No.16 with an overall score of 80.9.
Acquiring Immovable Property and Office Set Up is Easier in Dubai.
If you look at the individual parameters, the UAE scores higher than Singapore in ‘Getting Electricity’, ‘Getting Construction Permits’, and ‘Registering Property’. The UAE has given considerable attention to upgrading energy support to power-intensive industries, specifically – transport, construction, and services.
It takes just under 2 days to complete property registration, while the total cost of submitting the application at the Registration Trustee’s office along with the recording of title is about AED 14,000 (AED 4,000 for the application + AED 10,000 for Registration of Title).
Acquiring and registering the title deeds to your property could take up to 8 days in Singapore and could cost up to 2.9% of the property value.
Criteria for Business Establishment in UAE vs Singapore
- Singapore mandates that locally-held businesses have a resident director and that foreign-owned businesses with foreign owners who will be responsible for managing their operations from abroad must have a nominated director. Nominated directors are not necessary to start a business in Dubai.
- Nevertheless, Dubai mandates that a manager be chosen to supervise operations for the business. The registration cannot be accepted unless the management is on board.
- A minimum paid-in capital of S$1 is required by Singapore. Dubai does not have any minimum capital requirements. To remain credible with investors and the government, however, you must have paid-up capital of a minimum of 300,000 AED.
Starting a Business
As far as launching your business is concerned, both Singapore and Dubai have no minimum capital requirement paid-in. Actually, Singapore needs just $1 as the paid-in capital base.
However, Singapore company registration takes just 1.5 days (LLC) while it takes 3.5 days for the equivalent (LLP) in the UAE. In terms of cost, the registration procedure costs 17.2% of the income per capita in the UAE, it costs just 0.4% of the income per capita in Singapore. These figures assume all your documentation is in place and that filling in a form is the only major process remaining.
Company Registration Process in the UAE Vs Singapore
| UAE | Singapore |
|---|---|
|
|
| No Requirement to hire Local Officer or Director | Get a Local Corporate Secretary (usually with an accounting & reporting package) & Local Nominee Director |
NOTE: The most popular form of business entity for foreigners in the UAE is the Limited Liability Company (LLC). This has the same meaning as anywhere else in the world. However, in practice, you would need a paid-up capital of at least AED 300,000.
In Singapore, a number of companies register their LLCs with paid-up capitals of $1. However, a higher amount is recommended to maintain credibility among investors and the government.
Read More: Nominee Director
Foreign Ownership in UAE vs Singapore
Note that Singapore allows foreigners to own 100% of the shares of the company they form in Singapore. It will also allow reputed professionals, entrepreneurs, and specialists easier visa and relocation processes including permanent residency.
The UAE doesn’t allow foreigners to own more than 49% of the shares of a local company. You also cannot obtain UAE citizenship unless you are born there. Instead, you get a temporary visa that will serve you for just 3 years at a time.
Affinity to Global English
When you register your company in the UAE, you will need someone who knows Arabic. Certain documentation and forms will have to be filed in Arabic.
On the other hand, Singapore has a close affinity with India and English. Singapore actually insists that you complete all forms and submit documents in English.
Corporate Governance & Bureaucracy
Apart from insisting on compliance filing etc. to be conducted in Arabic, the Emirati bureaucracy insists on personal visits for certain procedures. Sometimes, this can add delay and consequently inflate your cost of doing business.
Singapore has successfully digitized nearly all of its processes so that you don’t have to be physically present while registering your company or performing associated transactions.
Certain requirements such as the use of a local Company Secretary and a local Director ensure standardization. However, professional firms and services exist that will handle this part for you without causing any hassles.
Read More: Singapore Free Trade Zones
Immigration Possibilities in UAE vs Singapore
The UAE’s Golden Visa is the most well-known immigration policy. This is a visa for a long-term stay with a validity of five to ten years. Talented persons from abroad who match the eligibility standards are eligible for this visa. This visa allows individuals and their families to settle down, start enterprises, and take advantage of extended residency privileges.
After your firm is incorporated in Singapore, you may submit an application for an Employment Pass on behalf of the new business. The pass will only be approved if the eligibility conditions and current government regulations are met. Upon approval of your pass, your relatives will also be qualified to move on the Dependant Pass visa.
Corporate Income Tax Rates: Singapore Vs. the UAE
Corporate Income Tax Rates Singapore and the UAE: 2021
UAE VAT Vs Singapore GST
Exemptions from GST/VAT Registration
Customs Duties & Stamp Duties
Fees for Licenses & Permits in the UAE (Dubai)
Every foreigner starting a business in the UAE will have to either pay for an Instant License Fee or set up a digital Memorandum of Association (MOA). He/she can also skip this step and instead, submit the MOA through a notary when applying for renewal of the License after year one.
NOTE: Although it would appear that the UAE has lower business set-up costs than Singapore, in practice, businesses end up having to pay higher expenses due to the high trade license fees, road, property, and hotel taxes.
Fees for Obtaining Instant License for Businesses in the UAE/Dubai
Tax Deductions and Tax Exemptions in Singapore (New Startups)
TAX EXEMPTION SCHEME FOR NEW STARTUPS, YA 2021 (APPLICABLE FOR FIRST 3 YAs)
PARTIAL TAX EXEMPTION SCHEME FOR QUALIFYING COMPANIES YA 2021
Skilled worker availability in Singapore and Dubai
Dubai and Singapore prioritize the attraction and retention of a talented workforce, benefiting from their diverse and international populations that include numerous highly educated and experienced professionals from various parts of the globe.
Both the UAE and Singapore prioritize offering excellent education, leading to impressive employment rates and a highly skilled workforce. In the IMD World Talent Ranking (WTR 2022), the UAE secured the top spot in the Arab region and rose two positions to rank 21st globally. Meanwhile, Singapore achieved the 12th position in the global rankings.
Conclusion
The decision of setting up an enterprise in the UAE and Singapore is influenced by a number of variables, including the type of business, capital requirement, tax exemptions, and so on. Singapore’s infrastructure is very advanced, and there are several business startup incentives available as well as tax advantages. The UAE has a diverse economy and provides tax breaks for firms. In order to have a successful business, it is crucial to carefully plan out and take into account the various variables while establishing a company.
You must choose a jurisdiction that will help you set up a successful business enterprise. For any questions, you can speak with our experts at Odint Consulting.
FAQ’s
Yes. Wives in the UAE must obtain permission from their husbands to step outside the marital home or be disobedient to them. It takes 1 day longer for women to register businesses in the UAE than men.
Yes. Native workers must be registered by foreign employers with the Ministry of Human Resources and the Authority for Pension and Social Security.
Foreign ownership of capital can go up to 100% in Free Trade Zones within the UAE. However, considerable restrictions apply and companies operating in FTAs within the UAE are subject to strict restrictions including obtaining a place of residence and business within the Free Trade Zone.
The decision of setting up an enterprise in the UAE and Singapore is influenced by a number of variables, including the type of business, capital requirement, tax exemptions, market conditions, access to capital, and so on.
